Leadership Council Endorses Wesleyan Paper on Homosexuality
Practical and pastoral guidance for congregations
Brethren in Christ U.S. believes that God’s design for sexual intimacy is limited to marriage between a man and a woman. This position is clearly stated in our Manual of Doctrine and Government (MDG): first in the Relationships in Creation section of Article II of the Articles of Faith and Doctrine (MDG, 2022, pg. 6), and again in Article 1.3 of the Statements of Christian Life and Practice (MDG, 2022, pg. 19). Our position is further developed in our Accents and Issues Paper on Human Sexuality.
The above documents clearly define our theology of human sexuality; however, they do not provide guidance for pastors and local church leaders navigating the practical application of this belief when it comes to homosexuality. We hope in this publication to do so.
In December 2023, the Wesleyan Church published a paper detailing their theological stance regarding homosexuality and offering “a series of practical and pastoral commitments.” At its meetings in February 2024, the Leadership Council of Brethren in Christ U.S. reviewed the Wesleyan Church’s statement and endorsed it as one that also represents the Brethren in Christ’s theology and perspective of homosexuality. You can read the paper below.
“Our desire is to love all people well and to help congregations as they wrestle with the realities of being salt and light in our world,” wrote Alan Robinson in his 2023 National Director’s report. “We want to be like Jesus, full of grace and truth, and we admit this is not easy.” We offer this statement to provide some guidance for congregations facing challenging decisions and conversations related to homosexuality.
The Wesleyan Church and Homosexuality
The Wesleyan Church aims to approach questions over homosexuality as we do all matters—with grace and truth, rooted in Scripture, guided by the Spirit with love, and confident that even God’s difficult commands are for our good.1
Wesleyans affirm a Biblical ethic of marriage and sexuality (outlined below) as part of God’s design for human flourishing.
Yet we also confess that the church has not always done well to love and pastor those who experience homosexual desires. Same-sex attraction remains a deeply personal subject in our homes and churches because it involves people whom God loves: family, friends, and sometimes even ourselves. Wesleyans seek therefore to frame the matter not primarily as a political or cultural “issue”—but as an opportunity to love God and neighbor as Christ commands us (Mark 12:30–31).
No person is beyond God’s saving grace; and no person is exempt from God’s empowering call to holiness. Though our sexuality is not the most important thing about us, it matters deeply because God has made us, we were bought by Christ at a price, and our bodies are to be temples of the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 6:19–20).
The Focus of this Statement
Before turning to Scripture, it is important to clarify our focus and our language to avoid misunderstanding.
First, this paper deals only with homosexuality rather than the full range of subjects sometimes located beneath the LGBTQ+ umbrella. This decision does not discount the importance of, say, transgender questions or intersex conditions; rather, it recognizes that those topics are distinct and significant enough to deserve their own response.
Second, Christians must be careful not to equate sexual temptation—or even sexual orientation—with sexual sin. Temptation and willful sin stand distinct within Wesleyan theology, as do one’s fallen inclinations and one’s fundamental identity as an image-bearer of God (Genesis 1:26) and a new creation in Christ Jesus (1 Corinthians 10:13; 2 Corinthians 5:17).
Third, our intention is to speak about homosexuality according to the same Biblical principles by which we approach sexuality in general. We do not therefore wish to isolate those who experience same-sex sexual desires as if they alone battle for sexual holiness. We are in this struggle together. All persons must submit their sexuality to what Scripture commands, to be conformed to God’s holy and loving will.
Fourth, since Wesleyans cherish both Biblical conviction and compassionate application, this paper begins with what Scripture teaches before moving to a series of practical and pastoral commitments.
What Scripture Teaches
Wesleyans stand with the vast majority of Christians—across continents, centuries, and church traditions—who read the Bible as prohibiting all same-sex sexual relationships. We do not seek to force this view upon society (1 Corinthians 5:12), but neither are we ashamed of it, since it aligns with God’s will for the good of all people.
The following points offer a brief outline of our Biblical convictions:
While Scripture must be carefully interpreted, we take heart that our reading of the Bible on sexual holiness stands in harmony with that of countless other Christians throughout the ages.
On Marriage and Celibacy in God’s Family
Wesleyans confess that until we reclaim a Christian account of celibacy, marriage, and the church as family—our good news for those experiencing same-sex temptation will be both unbiblical and impoverished.
Jesus, Paul, and countless saints across the centuries model and affirm that celibacy may be a rich and fruitful calling (1 Corinthians 7:7). And while the celibate life sets aside both marriage and sexual activity, it does not sacrifice deep friendship, possible leadership, and a place of honor in God’s house. Hence, Wesleyans seek to reclaim celibacy—alongside the spousal life—as a foretaste of the age to come (Mark 12:24–25; 1 Corinthians 7:8, 32–35, 38, 39b).
Christ himself reoriented the ancient notion of “family” around obedient faith in him (Mark 3:35; 10:29–30). Thus, early Christians spoke of one another as “brothers and sisters” in recognition that the Spirit has knit together the church not as a gathering of individuals or nuclear households, but as a family that makes space around the table for widows, orphans, married, and celibate persons.
Questions of Identity and Self-Description
Though many important and unique factors make us who we are, Wesleyans celebrate that the believer’s most important identity is found in Christ as a part of God’s new creation (2 Corinthians 5:17; Galatians 3:28; Ephesians 1:4,7). Thus, when Paul speaks to Christians about their former sinful habits and lifestyles, he does so in the past tense:
“And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:11; emphasis added).
Wesleyans therefore encourage all people to find their deepest identity as beloved image-bearers of God, and (for Christians) new creations being transformed by the Spirit of Christ Jesus.
At the same time, we acknowledge the value of being honest about our unchosen inclinations. To deny or hide these aspects of our lives may push us further from community and impede our Christian transformation.
For this reason, some Christians speak of being gay or lesbian not as an endorsement of homosexual practice, but as honest testimony to their unchosen inclinations. Other committed Christ-followers speak of being “celibate gay Christians” as a way of naming both their fallen predispositions and their faithful pursuit of sexual purity. These celibate Christians often face tremendous misunderstanding from all sides. How then should we proceed?
There is room for disagreement on some questions of terminology and self-description. Yet we offer the following advice with the goal of Christian charity and moral clarity:
It is important to name our fallen struggles, but it is even more important to discover and live out our deepest belonging and identity as beloved children of God.
Rejecting Two Forms of Religious Intolerance
Wesleyans oppose two forms of religious intolerance regarding homosexuality.
First, we reject and repent of the way our gay and lesbian neighbors have been mocked, bullied, ostracized, or even subjected to physical violence. Such actions do not represent the heart of Jesus, and they have no place within The Wesleyan Church. We also repent of an embarrassed silence that leaves those who experience same-sex sexual temptation to feel ignored, unseen, or unwanted. Though Wesleyan leaders—including pastors, professors, and staff members—commit to unapologetically uphold our Biblical convictions, we also call our communities to love and serve those who experience same-sex sexual temptation.
Second, Wesleyans also oppose a secular or progressive bigotry that seeks to punish or marginalize Christians for affirming what Scripture teaches. Though we do not expect the broader culture to share all our beliefs, we do seek to uphold basic freedoms of conscience, faith, and religious practice that are hallmarks of a free society. Disagreement does not equal hate. Nor is Biblical faith synonymous with bigoted fundamentalism. When religious freedoms are imperiled, Wesleyans commit to love those who oppose us, pray for them, and peaceably advocate for liberty and justice with a posture of respect (Matthew 5:43–48).
One way Wesleyans uphold our Christian convictions involves the kind of weddings we officiate and host. Though many nations recognize same-sex marriages, Wesleyan pastors do not preside over these unions, nor do we hold them in our churches. This decision stems not from a desire to be unkind toward friends and family who disagree, but from the biblical mandate that “we must obey God rather than human beings” (Acts 5:29).
Though “tolerance” is a watchword within modern culture, Wesleyans confess that love is both better and more costly than mere tolerance: Love compels us to go beyond begrudging coexistence to Biblical hospitality, honest conversation, joyful service, and truthful witness to the gospel of Christ Jesus.
Pastoral Conclusion
In the end, Wesleyans acknowledge that mere “statements” on homosexuality—however careful or Biblical—fall far short of what God asks. While Christ made bold pronouncements regarding sin and righteousness, he also shared more tables than he flipped. Thus, Jesus was criticized most frequently for the way sinners, outcasts, and religious outsiders were drawn to him, and Christ to them (Luke 15:2).
We conclude, therefore, with a call to patient pastoral care toward those who experience homosexual temptations. May we not sacrifice truth for sake of “love,” nor stop loving in the name of being truthful.
We grieve abusive reparative therapies even as we also reject the destructive modern myth—so pervasive in our culture and our media—that fallen longings represent one’s “true self” that must be obeyed. Hence, Christ’s command to his disciples was not “follow your heart,” but “follow me” (Matthew 4:19)—because he alone offers fullness of life (John 10:10).
Finally, we rejoice that hope and holiness are offered not only to a particular type of person or to a particular subset of fallen humanity. All are loved by God; all are made in his image; all are fallen; and all are called to be renewed by the grace of Jesus and the power of the Holy Spirit. Wesleyans believe in God’s transforming grace. And we rejoice together that we may raise our voices not merely in “statements” but in song:
He breaks the power of cancelled sin,
he sets the prisoner free;
his blood can make the foulest clean;
his blood availed for me.
* All Scripture quotations are from the NIV (2011) unless otherwise noted.
Notes
- Here we follow John Wesley’s affirmation that God’s commands are “covered promises” because they are given for our flourishing, and accompanied by a grace that enables our obedience. See John Wesley, “Upon our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount Discourse the Fifth (Sermon 25),” in The Works of John Wesley, ed. Albert C. Outler, Vol. 1: Sermons I, 1–33 (Nashville: Abingdon, 1984), II.3 (p. 555). ↩︎
